Hello guest, if you read this it means you are not registered. Click here to register in a few simple steps, you will enjoy all features of our Forum.
This forum uses cookies
This forum makes use of cookies to store your login information if you are registered, and your last visit if you are not. Cookies are small text documents stored on your computer; the cookies set by this forum can only be used on this website and pose no security risk. Cookies on this forum also track the specific topics you have read and when you last read them. Please confirm whether you accept or reject these cookies being set.

A cookie will be stored in your browser regardless of choice to prevent you being asked this question again. You will be able to change your cookie settings at any time using the link in the footer.

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Resistance
#1
I’ve always flown 4s 1300-1500mah packs and been used to good resistance being between 5-15ohms

However I’ve recently got into mini 6s either 550mah or 850mah

On my GNB batteries that are brand new on my 550mah batteries I’m seeing weird resistance numbers, sometimes not even that close to each other and at times up to 40ohms.

Is this normal??

I’m measuring resistance during charge with my Q8 charger

Any advice appreciated
Reply
Login to remove this ad | Register Here
#2
40 ohm is high. Maybe contact your vendor.
Reply
#3
It’s the same on 5 other brand new GNB 6s 550mah batteries!
Reply
#4
I should also mention this is their first charge.

I’ve heard that first charge resistance can be much higher than the following ones.... could that be it?
Reply
#5
That does seem like a really high resistance. The cells on my Tattu 4S LiPo which are now 2 years old all still read around 6-8mΩ on each cell.

Oscar's article states that you should consider retiring a LiPo if the resistance is anything over 20mΩ...

https://oscarliang.com/when-retire-lipo-battery

Do you have another charger you can use to confirm the resistance? If not then you can do it manually using the following method...

https://www.instructables.com/id/How-to-...f-a-batter
Reply
#6
Don’t have another charger and in a few Facebook groups I’ve asked people seem to suggest the following

1: GNB batteries tend to high have resistance than other makes anyway
2: the lower the MAH the higher the expected resistance is.

Oscars page clearly mentions on the average 1300-1500mah battery. So not sure his article accounts for the much smaller MAH.

I trust your guys opinions more than I trust my other sources but the fact I have 5 brand new batteries all showing very similar resistance readings makes me a little more comfortable(although not sure it should)

I’m also comfortable my ISDT Q8 is reading the resistance properly because I get much more expected results with my 1300-1500mah 4s batteries
Reply
#7
On my 4s 1500 cnhl batteries I get readings of about 6ohms

On my Tattu R-line 1300mah I also get around 6-7ohms

Sorry for the triple post. But I’m also told the first charge of a brand new battery can show much higher resistance so I will be checking the figures again after flying tomorrow
Reply
#8
you need a lipo checker!
i never had a new gnb with a near high resistance, i ordered replacements for batteries arrived at more than 10ohm... i would check it twice with another mesuring tool, sure i would get a replacement for every single pack!

dont use them bevor additional mesuring, contact the vendor
if your charger doesnt mesure correctly, you can destroy internal resistance of the batteries by the charger.
Reply
#9
I have the ISDT-BG8S battery checker but it’s doesn’t tell you resistance

The readings I’m giving are per cell, not for the entire battery

Again I’m comfortable the ISDT Q8 readings are correct

Gonna fly them tomorrow and then check the resistance again

I’m almost certain on all my batteries that the first charge I got a higher resistance reading than after cycling them once or twice.
Reply
#10
What Lipo checker can check the resistance of each cell?
Reply
#11
i got a very old voltcraft checker, i bought a very tiny (smaller than many lipocheckers) charger from toolkitrc m600 its 20bucks, i use it as lipochecker on the field, both can read the internal resistance of each cell.

isdt works very nice normaly, as you described your other lipos... probably the other lipos resistance is enough comparison. i would like replacement without any flighttesting or balancing.
Reply
#12
So i thought i would keep you all up to date. My thoughts were confirmed today (and in line what a lot of others said).

So my first charge of the brand new batteries showed resistance levels of around 34-40ohms. This had me worried hence my post above.

I went out over the weekend, and flew all the packs down to 3.8 per cell.

The second charge of the same brand new batteries now shows 15-20ohms

I am flying again tomorrow, so will check the levels after a 3rd charge and report back here!
Reply
#13
That's good news. Hopefully you mean milliohms and not ohms Big Grin
Reply
#14
Sorry yes Milliohms. Smile
Reply
#15
I beg you pardon in advance for not having opened a new thread but I have a couple of questions regarding IR that possibly could help broadening the original topic :-)

Being a loyal Tattu owner I was surfing the net looking for some new lipos but I stumbled upon Ovonic brand. Intrigued by their low prices decided to give them a try and buy a few 6s 1000.

I couldn’t make a worse choice :-(

Since the first charge I found each cell was showing values around 15-20 Milliohms, values that even my one years old Tattus never displayed a single damn time.
Those values are getting a bit lower after first cycle but keep staying above 10 Milliohms.

I'm not much confident in their reliability, do you think I should return them?
Reply


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Tenergy 5-in-1 cell meter internal resistance Pekka 1 729 05-Jun-2022, 01:47 AM
Last Post: kafie1980
  my first 6s lipo - doubts internal resistance Corrado-c 3 999 17-Jan-2021, 06:26 PM
Last Post: Ben975
  Apparently abnormal internal resistance on 6S pack mivo 4 958 24-Feb-2020, 02:20 PM
Last Post: mivo


Login to remove this ad | Register Here