Hello guest, if you read this it means you are not registered. Click here to register in a few simple steps, you will enjoy all features of our Forum.
This forum uses cookies
This forum makes use of cookies to store your login information if you are registered, and your last visit if you are not. Cookies are small text documents stored on your computer; the cookies set by this forum can only be used on this website and pose no security risk. Cookies on this forum also track the specific topics you have read and when you last read them. Please confirm whether you accept or reject these cookies being set.

A cookie will be stored in your browser regardless of choice to prevent you being asked this question again. You will be able to change your cookie settings at any time using the link in the footer.

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Choosing a motor/ESC combo
#1
I am building a 3S freestyle micro and have a 15A aio laying around so I will be using that. 

I am looking at motors and have heard good things about Emax Eco motors, but looking at the spec table I'm confused. 

I believe that I have to have motors that will pull no more than 15A...looking on the website below, however, the tables show peak current at 10S, yet these motors are rated for 2-4s???   

https://emaxmodel.com/products/emax-eco-...g-rc-drone#

So if I look at the 3300KV model, it says 17.7A...but at 3S is that lower?

I feel very lost.  Any help is appreciated, thank you.
Proud team pilot for brands I love: Dquad - Happymodel - Gemfan
Reply
Login to remove this ad | Register Here
#2
if the 17.7a are peak, it should work with 15a esc on 4s. what brand or model is your esc?

the ampdraw would be lower at 3s, around 13a peak

what eco motor did you aim?
the good things i heard about eco motors was all about the 5inch motors, i still prefer the highend motorline from emax on micromotors.. while the 5inch motors work and are half the price of a highend, its not a hige difference on micromotors. eco motors has a lower technology/manufacturing level.
i use the emax rs1306b 4000kv motors, they are pretty ok
Reply
#3
Thank you - how are you coming to 13a peak on 3s? Just so I understand. And what does the 10S mean?

The AIO I am using is Fettec mini 15A. I was thinking of the Eco 1407 3300A or 4100A. A friend recommended the HGLRC 1407 3600KV motors - he runs a full size hero 8 on his micro at times, and says those motors run extremely well, although he runs it on 4S. Plus the HGLRC are currently $43 for 4 on Amazon so I am debating those as well.
Proud team pilot for brands I love: Dquad - Happymodel - Gemfan
Reply
#4
thats just experience and what i would expect as max current, so lets making a bill:

the general rule is about rpm, as more rpm as more current. 4s is 1/4 more rpm: 17,7a / 4cell = 4.425a
4,425a x 3 = 13.275a
as lower cell count is always gives a littlebit higher current for the same trust, it needs a bit addition. lets say 0.735a ;-) it gives peak of 14a. im sure you will stay under 15a peak on 3s, but the current is also a tiny indicator for power, dont forget it will be slower and less powerfull on 3s.

(edit: there is another indicator about max power, if a motor does provide a very high max trust for its size, it also going to be inefficiency and produce heat and an unproportional current. while lower cell count does have a bit higher ampdraw for the same trust in general, it changes when we are going to ask for more than a motor like to provide, if it heats up next to an awesome performance.)


the rating of 15a is for 1106 up to an efficiency 1404 or 1306 motor on 3s. a powerfull 1406-1408 draws up to 20a.
while its only rated for 15a, fettec is quality stuff and i believe it can handle a peak current of 20a on a lightweight build... i dont see an issue regardless that rating.
anyway, 1106/1204/1206/1207/1303... will fit the esc rating perfectly and gives very nice lightweight builds, powerfull and efficiency .... if you dont have a reason like many 650mah-850mah batteries which would fit 140x motors, i would go for a lightweight sal motor 3inch.
the difference between them is a bit better topend on the bigger motors and better efficiency and durability on the smaller ones... both are awesome powerfull in regular flying rpms.
Reply
#5
Wow, thank you for taking the time to explain all that!

I do have some 1303 5000kv motors laying around, maybe I will try those...
Proud team pilot for brands I love: Dquad - Happymodel - Gemfan
Reply
#6
10S = 10 seconds
They are saying it is "peak" rating

The ESC rating is using good airflow, and is based on Rdson, and Tp.. the FET resistance when closed, and thus heat, and its package heat disipation rating.

Over the years ESC are marketed more "optimistically".
A 30A ESC made by Company A, can be branded as 40A by Company B. ie DarwinFPV.

A 15A AIO, almost always uses 2-N channel half bridge.
They are VERY susceptible to heat failure.
I have drawer of broken FC and most are 13A,15A,20A AIO FC.

I would not use anything bigger than 3" and 1204 with one of those.
[-] The following 1 user Likes romangpro's post:
  • JinxFPV
Reply
#7
darwinfpv is the best example, an eachine 30a esc rebranded with darwinfpv and rated for 40a xD customers are attracted by the 10a higher rating, thats the issue, that marketing works Undecided
[-] The following 1 user Likes hugnosed_bat's post:
  • JinxFPV
Reply
#8
What does it mean when it says active current limiting: 15A? I'm assuming that's protection?
Proud team pilot for brands I love: Dquad - Happymodel - Gemfan
Reply
#9
I don't know much about KISS's ESC firmware (it's closed source - no one does) but it should do. Assuming it's the same as the BLHeli32 feature it should protect itself by biting down on the current draw if the motors start pulling too much.

The ground is for dead people.
[-] The following 1 user Likes Banelle's post:
  • JinxFPV
Reply
#10
limiting isnt truly what we like xD it wont help to protect the electronics in a crash, crashes are the most often situations where escs burnout.
[-] The following 1 user Likes hugnosed_bat's post:
  • JinxFPV
Reply


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
Question Help Diatone MXC Taycon Cinewhoop's 4th motor isn't working rr240 2 63 Yesterday, 02:58 PM
Last Post: Pathfinder075
Question Help Diatone MXC Taycon Cinewhoop's 4th motor isn't working rr240 0 46 23-Apr-2024, 09:36 PM
Last Post: rr240
  Help TMotor F55 Pro ii ESC won't power FC after crash EyeBotXander 2 277 11-Apr-2024, 09:32 PM
Last Post: EyeBotXander
  Solved ESC and FC rebooting during motortest zsolth 5 129 11-Apr-2024, 01:34 PM
Last Post: zsolth
  Sometimes a motor surprises you - in a good way mstc 20 810 10-Apr-2024, 09:00 PM
Last Post: mstc


Login to remove this ad | Register Here